Tesla, Inc., the electric vehicle (EV) giant led by Elon Musk, has long been synonymous with rapid growth and innovation. However, recent developments have cast doubt on the sustainability of its growth trajectory. Shockingly low quarterly sales figures have raised a fundamental question for investors: If the days of breakneck growth are over, what are Tesla’s shares truly worth?
Sales Disappointment and Growth Falters
In the first quarter of 2024, Tesla sold approximately 387,000 cars—a significant miss compared to Wall Street’s average expectation of around 449,000. The wide margin between actual sales and projections has prompted concerns about the company’s demand problem. Analysts wonder whether this shortfall is indicative of deeper challenges or merely a temporary setback.
Nicholas Colas, co-founder of DataTrek Research, highlights the lack of visibility regarding Tesla’s next growth phase. Whether it’s electric vehicles (EVs) or other projects, the uncertainty looms large. Premium valuation multiples demand strong earnings visibility or a compelling narrative about future earnings. At present, Tesla possesses neither.
The Sensitive Growth Issue
A recent report suggesting that Tesla was abandoning its low-cost EV plans—a crucial element in addressing its demand issues—sent shockwaves through the market. The stock plummeted more than 6% in response. Elon Musk swiftly refuted the report on social media, but the damage was done. The stock remains a heavyweight in the S&P 500.
Musk’s subsequent announcement about unveiling a “robotaxi” on August 8 added further intrigue. However, some experts question the timing. Gary Black, co-founder of Future Fund Advisors, emphasizes the need for a $25,000 compact vehicle to compete with other affordable EVs. Doubling down on a robotaxi venture at this juncture appears risky.
Tesla’s stock has faced significant headwinds in 2024, plunging 34% since January. It ranks as the largest drag on the Nasdaq 100 Index and the worst performer on the S&P 500 Index. Remarkably, approximately 76% of Tesla’s valuation hinges on its future earnings potential.
Caution Ahead
JPMorgan analyst Ryan Brinkman warns that Tesla’s shares could fall further if the company fails to restore unit volume and revenue growth promptly. The risk lies in losing its status as a hyper-growth company in investors’ eyes.
In conclusion, Tesla’s growth story faces unprecedented scrutiny. As the EV landscape evolves, the company must navigate challenges and prove its resilience in an ever-changing market.
Leave a comment